The great debate, should I spank my child or not, is back in the news.  Yahoo Parenting published an article (against spanking) that is making the rounds.  I found it interesting and informative if you are looking for motivation to refrain from spanking your kids most of the time.  I also found it interesting that the article ended with, “It’s OK to spank once in awhile…”

My personal opinion is that there is always a better option than spanking.  The argument that occasional swats are OK, just doesn’t fly for me.  There is always a discipline response that will teach your child to behavior better AND build their self-esteem at the same time.  Deciding To Spare the Rod is a personal choice that each parent needs to make.

That being said, I also think that it’s not reasonable to tell parents not to spank their kids without offering them options of what to do instead, like our article “9 Things To Do Instead of Spanking”.

I would like to share with you my personal story of deciding not to use spanking with my kids.  Twenty-three years ago I was in a battered woman’s shelter with my 3 kids, then aged 6, 2 & 9 months.  This shelter is where I had my first parenting class.  A woman would teach us about boundaries, setting limits, feelings…it was all very enlightening to me.  There was also a shelter rule — No Spanking!  I was a little miffed.  Why should I not be able to discipline my kids as I see fit?  In hindsight, the irony of being in a shelter for violence, yet using violence to discipline my children, was not lost on me.  So I shared with Abby, one of the shelter workers that I trusted, my concerns at being able to follow this rule.  She said, “Debbie, if you feel you need to spank one of your kids, come get me, or call me, and we’ll discuss your options and then you can decide what to do”.  So the next few days, I was seeking Abby constantly.  “This is what he’s doing, and I KNOW I need to spank him now!” I would plead.  She would talk me off the cliff, we would discuss what he was doing, and why he was doing it.  She would help me see another way to respond, and it was always BRILLIANT, something that corrected his misbehavior and built his self-esteem, and made be feel really good as a parent.

Within a couple weeks, I was calling on Abby less and less, trusting myself more and more, and my kids were responding better and better to my discipline.  I had a HUGE epiphany:

“No matter what the kids are doing, there is ALWAYS a better way to respond than spanking.  Discipline that fixes the misbehavior, yet teaches them the right thing to do for the right reasons, that doesn’t break their spirit, and makes me feel GREAT as a parent!”


This AHA has stayed with me for the past 23 years as a huge passion for conveying to others my excitement and enlightenment about discipline and punishment.  But I have never forgotten the fear, the uncertainty, of not knowing what to do instead.  If I let go of spanking, what will I do?  This is a valid fear and one reason I do the work I do.  It’s not fair to tell parents not to spank without providing the WHAT TO DO INSTEAD, which is my life’s work, and so much of what I teach in my classes.  In my classes, all parents have my cell phone number.  I am available 24-7 to help “talk a parent down off the cliff” if they are willing to call me before they spank and let me see if I can help them come up with a better solution.  It’s the least I can do, to give back the kindness offered to me by Abby, all those years ago.  And it’s a joy and an honor to help.

I look forward to you sharing your opinions, insights, and stories about your decision whether to spank or not.

Happy Parenting!


[email protected]

Do you need better attendance at your parent education programs? I split my time between So. California and Louisville, KY. If you are interested in parenting classes & workshops in a 3 hour radius of either, there are no travel fees. Please contact me for topics & rates. I love to travel & have an 8-week proposal for parenting workshops, intensive classes & instructor training in your area of the world. Please email me for details.


  1. Matthew Caldwell Says Reply

    The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that parents develop alternative methods to disciplining your child or children other then physical abuse, like spanking. Research and studies conducted by the American Academy of Pediatrics conclude that spanking a child is not only physically harmful, but is actually emotionally harmful to both the parent and the child. Although spanking a child may put a stop to the behavior you are disciplining your child for, it will only put a stop to it for a limited amount of time. It is better to teach your child by sitting them down and having a face to face discussion with them not only about why their behavior is not allowed, but also teaching them alternative behavior. Physical abuse and spanking can have a lasting negative effect on the parent and child’s relationship far into the future. It can also very easily lead to the child physically abusing their children once they are parents.

  2. Napoleon Nalcot Says Reply

    Discipline doesn’t always mean punishment and humiliation as what most people perceived it to be. It could be in many forms. What’s important is that, in getting your child to behave the way you wanted him or her to, you’re not losing his or her dignity in the process. But is it really possible to discipline a child without hitting him or her? Is it really necessary to spank your kids? Knowing how to discipline a child is never easy. As a parent, it is important to consider the fact that you can’t solve every problem concerning your kids but there are certain ways worth dealing with for that matter.

  3. Tiffany Says Reply

    How does a spanking help the situation!! It doesn’t. There are millions of ways you can discipline your child without causing harm to them.. So yes I agree

  4. Erin Steinhem Says Reply

    I really appreciate that you make a point to give other strategies of discipline instead of just saying, “don’t spank your children!” I agree with you. I think so many parents spank their children because they just don’t know what else to do.

Leave a Reply